Sailor Moon Manga All Color Edition - Discussion (Vol 3-4 announced)

  • This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more.

Lady Pen

Lumen Cinererum
Mar 12, 2021
419
1,141
1,665
Seriously, why don't they stick to this color palette?

Spoiler: show


Look at King's face. It seems they erased softly at the middle of every face, so they look a little oily.


For me, this color manga is a "what if Crystal had adapted this part" version of Sailor Moon.
After having a look (again) at the Act 1 displayed at the 2016 exhibition, I've seen how the backgrounds were coloured depending on Usagi's feelings or the scene mood in question.

Leaving white backgrounds in the official release makes this edition quite boring and bland.
 

MementoNepenthe

Systema Solare
Mar 8, 2012
5,654
6,363
1,665
underwatersphinx.blogspot.com
There are places where the white backgrounds work and make the characters pop even more, but a lot of the time it's just very "we waited two years for THIS?" Don't get me wrong, I still love these volumes and think they're beautiful and everything, but they could have been SO much more.

Maybe for the 50th anniversary we'll get a new color version of the manga. The Double Rainbow Moon Edition :lol:
 
Dec 1, 2020
793
2,025
1,665
31
To be honest, some of it looks nice. But then other times it kind of gives me ‘14 year olds first time coloring in manga pages with the Photoshop airbrush tool on a multiply layer’ type vibes.

Also, adding color to everything also makes Naoko’s questionable drawing skills more apparent. I feel like you can get away with something more sketchy and unpolished in black and white than you can with color.

I would be interested to hear what the hold up was beacuse this definitely does not scream 2 years in the making to me.
 
Last edited:
Likes: Starlight

Rika-Chicchi

Staff member
Site Admin
May 7, 2009
40,555
3,754
1,665
Also, adding color to everything also makes Naoko’s questionable drawing skills more apparent. I feel like you can get away with something more sketchy and unpolished in black and white than you can with color.
Maybe for the 50th anniversary we'll get a new color version of the manga. The Double Rainbow Moon Edition :lol:
W/ each & every panel redrawn like the artbook illustrations. :oh my: :googly:
 
Likes: Jawshx

Lady Pen

Lumen Cinererum
Mar 12, 2021
419
1,141
1,665
Also, adding color to everything also makes Naoko’s questionable drawing skills more apparent
I don't understand why she hasn't redrawn most of the panels of the Black Moon & Death Busters arcs after 3 editions, it's been almost 20 years since the shinshouban... laziness? Those 2 arcs look sketchy to me.
 

sapphire91

Systema Solare
Jul 6, 2018
5,821
8,016
1,665
I do not find the hate deserving. I know people are a bit salty with the franchise as a whole and we tend to nitpick about everything, but have you guys seen other color manga editions? While not perfect the Rainbow edition is done way better compared to most of them.
 
Likes: GuerreroLuna

Crystal Moon

Solaris Luna
Jul 11, 2013
2,919
2,344
1,665
30
I do not find the hate deserving. I know people are a bit salty with the franchise as a whole and we tend to nitpick about everything, but have you guys seen other color manga editions? While not perfect the Rainbow edition is done way better compared to most of them.
I will be salty if they don't release the physical copy. Because this way of coloring is indeed for the purpose of ink saving.
 

Starlight

Aurorae Lunares
May 31, 2009
1,115
911
665
Tankei Kingdom, Kinmoku
I know people are a bit salty with the franchise as a whole and we tend to nitpick about everything, but have you guys seen other color manga editions? While not perfect the Rainbow edition is done way better compared to most of them.
I've seen the color edition of Sugar Sugar Rune--incidently another magical girl manga serialized in Nakayoshi and published by Kodansha--and it's way better than Sailor Moon's. They colored in the backgrounds, there's no grayscale, and the colors pop!
 

sapphire91

Systema Solare
Jul 6, 2018
5,821
8,016
1,665
I've seen the color edition of Sugar Sugar Rune--incidently another magical girl manga serialized in Nakayoshi and published by Kodansha--and it's way better than Sailor Moon's. They colored in the backgrounds, there's no grayscale, and the colors pop!
To me it has that overdigital smoothness that flattens the artwork and turns it into the likes of these web comics, but people have preferences.I still find it pretty good and it is so underrated. Do you know if the anime is as good as the manga>