The difference between Crystal/Eternal and the manga is that the latter has passion, energy and heart, regardless its quality. Crystal lacks all those attributes due to the ignorance of today's executives in Toei and Kodansha who don't know at all why Sailor Moon was a success and why it's still so beloved in the world. They've taken the franchise for granted because of the title and its fame.
Crystal isn't an adaptation, it's just a carbon copy (a bad copy) with some little variations of the comic and 90's stock footage for attacks and transformations. Sailor Moon needs a new team who cares for it, not Toei's men in suits relying upon Osano and his 'the comic is wonderful, flawless and eternal.'
This I definitely agree with, without actual talent like Ikuhara and Sato on board, Toei has mismanaged this IP every step of the way, even before they completely mangled Crystal (see SuperS). I have always been the first one to say that what Sailor Moon really needs is a new studio, one that actually cares and isn’t just in it to sell toys/merch. There’s a reason why Miyazaki left Toei and took a bunch of staff with him to form Ghibli - Toei truly does live up to its “Disney of Japan” moniker they penned themselves, but more like the new Disney which is a soulless, capatalist imperialist which buys up practically every other studio and franchise in existence all while it shits out lazy, worse, live-action remakes of their classics because they feel they no longer need to put in any effort and can ride off the coattails of their brand name. A studio like Kyoani or Bones would’ve treated Sailor Moon with much more care.
But is your problem with Crystal just that it’s a
bad copy of the manga or that it’s a copy at all? Would you have been satisfied if it was an exact copy of the manga only done with the care another studio could’ve given it or did you not want a direct 1:1 manga adaptation to begin with? Keep in mind that if it’s the latter, plenty of manga fans hold the manga in high regard and have been begging for a straight anime adaptation for ages now, just like franchises such as Fullmetal Alchemist and Fruits Basket got - why should those fans be deprived of a faithful adaptation when pretty much every unfaithful manga adaptation is getting the “Brotherhood” treatment? Don’t those manga fans deserve their own “Brotherhood” version of the manga? A well done, beautifully animated,
actually faithful panel by panel adaptation with no weird editions and no cuts whatsoever. Why can’t the manga fans have that adaptation they’ve long been waiting for, while the IP also continues to create original, alternate interpretations of the franchise side-by side? I feel like it shouldn’t be an either-or situation and the fandom
can and
should have both. One animated panel by panel adaptation of the manga wouldn’t kill the fandom, so long as that’s the only one made and future versions continue going with their own original visions or combining elements of both the manga & 90’s anime, expanding on the manga, etc.
I mean, Rei is a complete different character in the 90's but thanks to the manga, Casablanca story, one can get the reason why she lives with her grandpa.
But see we actually don’t know the reason why Rei lives with her grandpa in the 90’s anime, seeing as the 90’s anime never delved into her backstory and we cannot just automatically apply manga canon to the 90’s since they’re two separate universes - heck, never mind Rei, even Grandpa Hino himself is a completely different person. Both the manga and 90’s anime were written by completely different people, the manga by Naoko and Osabu, and the anime by Sato, Ikuhara, Igarashi and an assortment of other Toei writers. Naturally these different writing teams each brings with them their own perspective and interpretation of what Sailor Moon “should be.” Not unlike the old Optimum dub’s interpretation or even Saban Moon’s, heck even PGSM and the Musicals have their own wholly original elements because the nature of Sailor Moon as a franchise has always been a different team of writers handling each of their versions and shaping Sailor Moon into what
they think the IP should be.
The only thing that’s remained consistent between all the versions is the concept of the 5 Inners and the Cats, Past Lives/Silver Millenium, the Miracle Romance, and the villain & civilian designs and concepts - everything else, each different writing team shaped to their liking in order to tell their own version of Sailor Moon. Sailor Moon as an IP is less of one consistent story and more just an amalgamation of ideas using key outlined concepts that each writer uses in their own way. (Heck this can be seen even with the billed as a straight manga adaption Crystal during it’s DK and BM arcs, for better or for worse) It is truly an entire
franchise in every sense of the word.
Sometimes I think Naoko is his sister or a cousin he uses in public appearances and the original author is him.
I mean considering Osabu technically created the concept of Sailor Moon himself, you’re not that far off, lol.